Why alternate the starting side?
Milk supply works on demand: the more often and thoroughly a breast is emptied, the more milk it makes. If you always start on the same side, that breast gets more stimulation and the other gets less. Over time, this can lead to a noticeable difference in supply, along with fullness and discomfort on one side.
That is why the UK National Health Service (NHS) recommends offering both breasts at each feed and alternating which breast you start with. The AAP agrees, advising parents to alternate the breast offered first at each feeding, even if their baby clearly prefers one side.
How a feed should go
- Start on the first breast and let your baby feed until they come off on their own. When sucking and swallowing slow down and your baby relaxes, they are done with that side.
- Burp your baby and offer the second breast.
- Your baby may not want the second side. That can simply mean they are full. Start the next feed on that breast.
Some NHS hospital leaflets also suggest switching to the second breast as your baby's sucking slows and before they fall into a deep sleep, then going back to the first if needed. This can help sleepy newborns take in more milk.
There is no need to time feeds by the minute or to switch sides after a set number of minutes. Follow your baby's cues instead. For how often newborns feed, see our article on how often a newborn should breastfeed.
How to remember which side is next
Remembering which side you finished on at 3 a.m. is harder than it sounds. A few practical options:
- Check for fullness: At the next feed, the breast that feels fuller is usually the one to start with.
- Use a simple marker: The AAP suggests moving a safety pin from one strap of your nursing bra to the other after each feed. A hair tie or bracelet on your wrist works the same way.
- Keep a log: A notebook or an app can show both the last side and the time of the last feed.
If one breast makes less milk
Most parents find that one breast produces a little more milk than the other. This is common because each breast can contain a different amount of milk-making tissue, and nobody is perfectly symmetrical. The Australian Breastfeeding Association notes that one breast may keep producing more than the other, and that this is acceptable. If your baby is gaining weight well and has enough wet diapers, there is no need to worry (see our article on wet diapers by day).
If you would like to boost the lower-producing side:
- Start feeds on that side more often.
- Feed or pump from that side more often, in shorter sessions.
- Make sure your baby is latching well on that side. If they are struggling, ask a lactation consultant for help.
If you pump
It is also common to pump less milk from one side than the other, and on its own that is not a problem. The Australian Breastfeeding Association suggests shorter, more frequent pumping sessions on a breast you want to make more milk. Writing down the amount from each side separately makes it easier to see changes over time. Keep in mind that what you pump is not always a perfect reflection of how much your baby gets when feeding directly.
If your baby refuses one side
Some babies refuse one breast or are fussier on one side. The reason is often simple: the milk may flow faster or slower on that side, or your baby may not be able to get comfortable in that position. Sometimes the baby has a discomfort of their own, such as pain when turning their head to that side. Trying a different hold, like the football (clutch) hold, often helps. If the refusal starts suddenly or lasts for days, talk to your pediatrician.
When to call the doctor
Contact your doctor, midwife or lactation consultant if you notice:
- A red, swollen, hot and painful area on the breast, especially with fever, chills or flu-like aches. This may be mastitis. The NHS advises seeing a GP if symptoms don't improve within 12–24 hours of self-care, or sooner if you feel worse at any point.
- Pus or blood in your milk, or red streaks on the breast.
- A hard lump in the breast that doesn't go away.
- Cracked or bleeding nipples, or pain that lasts throughout feeds.
- Your baby isn't gaining weight, has fewer wet diapers, or suddenly and consistently refuses one breast.
According to the NHS, continuing to breastfeed during mastitis won't harm your baby, and it can help you recover.
How to track the next side in Agu
In Agu, you start the left or right side with a single tap, and switching sides during a feed is one tap too. Agu records the last side, and the home screen widget shows how long it has been since the last feed and which breast is next. On iPhone, the Live Activity on the lock screen shows the same information, and on Android the timer in the notification does too. All of this is free.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to offer both breasts at every feed?
No. Offer the second side, but don't force it if your baby isn't interested. Starting the next feed on that side keeps things balanced.
My baby always falls asleep on the first side. What should I do?
Gently compressing your breast when sucking slows, or rousing your baby and moving them to the other side, can help. This is very common with sleepy newborns.
My breasts are different sizes now. Is that normal?
During breastfeeding, one breast may look a little larger or feel fuller than the other. This is common and usually becomes less noticeable after breastfeeding ends. If it comes with pain, redness or a lump, see your doctor.
Sources
- Breastfeeding: is my baby getting enough milk? — NHS
- Breastfeeding: your questions answered — NHS
- Settling In: The First Few Weeks of Breastfeeding — American Academy of Pediatrics (HealthyChildren.org)
- Mastitis — NHS Start for Life
- Mastitis — NHS 111 Wales
- Breastfeeding: one side preference — HSE (Ireland's Health Service)
- Australian Breastfeeding Association — Australian Breastfeeding Association
This article is for information only and is not medical advice. Follow your doctor's advice for decisions about your baby's health.